Friday: First Post ft. Vegas' New Golden Knight
Hey y'all (I'm from Georgia, get used to it), I'm the new Friday writer here at HJC, TC Moore. I've been submitting to the site for a while, and I'm really excited to join the team and give back to the site and the readers. First off, I would like to thank my predecessor, Steven G. The whole team here at Hockey Jersey Concepts has appreciated all that he has done for the site during both of his terms here, and wish him all the best going forward.
Now to the news:
In other news, be on the lookout later today for the new COTW poll, as well as the poll for the Random Competition. Polls run until next Friday at Noon Eastern
Now on to today's concepts!
Anthony C.- Vancouver Canucks
First up, we have Anthony C. with a concept for the Canucks. Let's start with the positives: I like the initiative you took with the creation of your own logo. It shows an added level of creativity on your part, and I applaud you for that. I also like the idea of the yoke striping that goes along with the arm and hem striping patterns. Furthermore, I appreciate you sticking to the '72-'78 striping pattern that the Canucks used, a really classic pattern. Now for the negatives: I'm going to be honest, it took me a little while to figure out what this logo was supposed to be. At first I thought it was for a Star Wars theme night like what some minor league teams have done, as it reminded me of a TIE fighter. While I do like it more now that I get what it is, I don't think it's strong enough to dethrone the stick-in-rink. Additionally, I like the idea of the yoke striping, but it's a little confusing with the mismatched striping between the dark and light jersey. Also, the colors aren't vibrant enough for a Canucks jersey. They look like a sun-bleached Canucks jersey, and I don't think it would work on ice. Finally, some execution errors: I believe others have mentioned this to you before, but just in case, make sure your stitching stops at the hem stripe. It's a simple fix with the paintbrush. Also, try to include the gear with your concepts, it gives a better idea of what the actual uniform will look like and the color balance. Last execution note: try to avoid white backgrounds so your light jersey doesn't bleed into the background. Final Verdict: 6.5/10
Brooks F.- Dallas Stars
Our next two entries come from Brooks F., who continues his nineties series. I'm a big fan of this series, because it offers a departure from the more traditional designs we usually get. I love the return of the gold to the uniforms, as I always felt the silver just fell too flat. I like the design of the stars gradually getting bigger, creating a unique take on the diagonal hem striping. I also like the arm and sock striping, with one small exception. I get that you're trying to match the outline of the stars on the hem stripe, but the top stripe on each jersey and sock is just way too thin and gets lost. Additionally, I would switch the black and white on the dark jersey, as the black and green might bleed into each other, and I think white stars would really pop. Also, I would probably make the hem striping a little smaller so that it doesn't run into the numbers on the back. Finally, I just don't like that striping on the pants. I would go with plain black pants or a script like they had in the nineties.
Final verdict: 7.5/10
Brooks F.- Detroit Red Wings
Brooks continues his nineties series with a concept for the Detroit Red Wings. I like the ambition with this one, as the Wings have had essentially the same uniform since 1961. I like the idea of the wings on the shoulders, similar to some of the seemingly endless uniform options of the Oregon Ducks football team, but I think in reality it would be too hard to achieve unless it was screen printed, as having it made up of patches would make the jersey heavy and unwieldy. I like the striping pattern, but on the hem I wouldn't have them converge, just make it more like a side striping with some blank space in the middle. I do like the continuation of the striping pattern on the pants, but I would have liked to see it on the socks as well. Finally, I think the font works really well with this concept. While it wouldn't quite fit on the normal Wings jersey, it meshes excellently with the more rounded, modern striping on this jersey. Final verdict: 8.5/10.
TC Moore: Providence College Friars
For my next two concepts, I have the tricky task of reviewing my own work without sounding too conceited. I'm going to try to be as objective as possible on this one, so here goes. I know that providence loves their hockey specific logo, but to me it belongs in the past. For some reason, it looks like a combo of Pittsburgh's skating penguin and the Robopenguin to me. I did make a concession to the fans of the logo by putting it on the third jersey. As for the jerseys themselves, I like the simplistic striping pattern, but looking back I don.t quite know if the middle white stripe on the light jersey is distinct enough or if it blends into the grey. I used the primary friars logo for the chest and the shield logo makes a fantastic shoulder patch. I also think that the Thrashers (RIP) font is a great fit with the font used in the shoulder patch. On the third jersey, I realize now that I eliminated white from the uniform, but it's still present in the logos. Not my best move. Final verdict: 7.5/10.
TC Moore- Murray State Racers
I chose Murray State here because they have a very unique mascot and I like their logos and color scheme. I understand that the yellow numbers on the light jersey may be hard to read, but when I tried to do it with the colors reversed, it just looked atrocious, so I stand by my decision. I really like the striping pattern, but it might be a bit too busy, especially with movement. The logo choices work well, I think. As for the third jersey, I fell into my old pattern of just eliminating the third color, but it works out okay here because you have the contrast of light and dark between the two colors. Looking back, I might eliminate the yellow helmet and just go with the blue, just to avoid an overload of yellow. Execution note: accidentally put the primary logo instead of the shoulder patch next to the third jersey. Rookie mistake. Final Verdict: 8.5/10
Since I have two concepts in this post, I'm going to leave it up to y'all to nominate who you want for the COTW. Let us know in the comments.
On a final note, I want to point something out to anyone contributing to this site. I, like everyone else on the HJC team, was brought on because I have a particular taste in jerseys that is different from the other members of the staff. That's part of what makes this site work, the fact that it's got a wide variety of opinions on concepts that are brought from the different writers. For example, most of the other guys who write for HJC absolutely HATE the jersey template that I use, but I find that it's the most user friendly, especially if you're just starting out, and it works for me. This subjectivity means that we aren't the be-all-end-all of concept designs. If you think we're wrong about your work, stand up for it and let us know why in the comments. Even if it isn't your concept, if you think we got a COTW nominee wrong, feel free to let us know. This site is meant for your opinions just as much as ours. This is a community.
That's it for me this week, I'll see y'all next Friday!
Now to the news:
While they await the expansion
draft in mid-June to field a full team, the NHL’s newest team is not completely
devoid of an idea of their roster. The
Vegas Golden Knights currently have one player signed to their team, Reid Duke,
a 6’, 192 lb., 21-year-old C/RW. Drafted
by the Wild in the 6th round of the 2014 draft, Duke has spent the
majority of his playing time in the WHL, most recently with the Brandon Wheat
Kings. Duke spent three years with the
Wheat Kings, including their 2015-2016 Chynoweth Cup winning
campaign, during which the racked up eight goals and sixteen assists in the
postseason. Duke totaled 184 points in 179 games
during his tenure in Brandon, and is currently under a player tryout contract
with the Chicago Wolves, the Blues’ AHL affiliate, but has been a healthy
scratch during the Wolves’ playoff run.
While he may lack major league
experience, Duke is still a relatively good sign overall for the NHL’s newest
franchise. His time with the Wheat Kings
gave him playoff experience and showed that he can produce points when it
really matters. His time with the Wolves
will serve as a nice stepping stone to get him more acclimated with the pace of
an NHL team, as opposed to his experience with WHL teams. Duke also has connections with the Golden
Knights, as his coach on the Wheat Kings, Kelly McCrimmon, is Vegas’ new
Assistant GM. Duke’s postseason
production and approval from the front office could be just what the Golden
Knights need in a first signee, but only time will tell if he can produce in
the NHL the same way that he could in the WHL.
In other news, be on the lookout later today for the new COTW poll, as well as the poll for the Random Competition. Polls run until next Friday at Noon Eastern
-------------------------------------
COTW April 28- May 4 vote (ends next Friday @ noon Eastern)
Random Competition vote (ends next Friday @ noon Eastern)
-------------------------------------
Anthony C.- Vancouver Canucks
First up, we have Anthony C. with a concept for the Canucks. Let's start with the positives: I like the initiative you took with the creation of your own logo. It shows an added level of creativity on your part, and I applaud you for that. I also like the idea of the yoke striping that goes along with the arm and hem striping patterns. Furthermore, I appreciate you sticking to the '72-'78 striping pattern that the Canucks used, a really classic pattern. Now for the negatives: I'm going to be honest, it took me a little while to figure out what this logo was supposed to be. At first I thought it was for a Star Wars theme night like what some minor league teams have done, as it reminded me of a TIE fighter. While I do like it more now that I get what it is, I don't think it's strong enough to dethrone the stick-in-rink. Additionally, I like the idea of the yoke striping, but it's a little confusing with the mismatched striping between the dark and light jersey. Also, the colors aren't vibrant enough for a Canucks jersey. They look like a sun-bleached Canucks jersey, and I don't think it would work on ice. Finally, some execution errors: I believe others have mentioned this to you before, but just in case, make sure your stitching stops at the hem stripe. It's a simple fix with the paintbrush. Also, try to include the gear with your concepts, it gives a better idea of what the actual uniform will look like and the color balance. Last execution note: try to avoid white backgrounds so your light jersey doesn't bleed into the background. Final Verdict: 6.5/10
Brooks F.- Dallas Stars
Our next two entries come from Brooks F., who continues his nineties series. I'm a big fan of this series, because it offers a departure from the more traditional designs we usually get. I love the return of the gold to the uniforms, as I always felt the silver just fell too flat. I like the design of the stars gradually getting bigger, creating a unique take on the diagonal hem striping. I also like the arm and sock striping, with one small exception. I get that you're trying to match the outline of the stars on the hem stripe, but the top stripe on each jersey and sock is just way too thin and gets lost. Additionally, I would switch the black and white on the dark jersey, as the black and green might bleed into each other, and I think white stars would really pop. Also, I would probably make the hem striping a little smaller so that it doesn't run into the numbers on the back. Finally, I just don't like that striping on the pants. I would go with plain black pants or a script like they had in the nineties.
Final verdict: 7.5/10
Brooks F.- Detroit Red Wings
Brooks continues his nineties series with a concept for the Detroit Red Wings. I like the ambition with this one, as the Wings have had essentially the same uniform since 1961. I like the idea of the wings on the shoulders, similar to some of the seemingly endless uniform options of the Oregon Ducks football team, but I think in reality it would be too hard to achieve unless it was screen printed, as having it made up of patches would make the jersey heavy and unwieldy. I like the striping pattern, but on the hem I wouldn't have them converge, just make it more like a side striping with some blank space in the middle. I do like the continuation of the striping pattern on the pants, but I would have liked to see it on the socks as well. Finally, I think the font works really well with this concept. While it wouldn't quite fit on the normal Wings jersey, it meshes excellently with the more rounded, modern striping on this jersey. Final verdict: 8.5/10.
TC Moore: Providence College Friars
For my next two concepts, I have the tricky task of reviewing my own work without sounding too conceited. I'm going to try to be as objective as possible on this one, so here goes. I know that providence loves their hockey specific logo, but to me it belongs in the past. For some reason, it looks like a combo of Pittsburgh's skating penguin and the Robopenguin to me. I did make a concession to the fans of the logo by putting it on the third jersey. As for the jerseys themselves, I like the simplistic striping pattern, but looking back I don.t quite know if the middle white stripe on the light jersey is distinct enough or if it blends into the grey. I used the primary friars logo for the chest and the shield logo makes a fantastic shoulder patch. I also think that the Thrashers (RIP) font is a great fit with the font used in the shoulder patch. On the third jersey, I realize now that I eliminated white from the uniform, but it's still present in the logos. Not my best move. Final verdict: 7.5/10.
TC Moore- Murray State Racers
I chose Murray State here because they have a very unique mascot and I like their logos and color scheme. I understand that the yellow numbers on the light jersey may be hard to read, but when I tried to do it with the colors reversed, it just looked atrocious, so I stand by my decision. I really like the striping pattern, but it might be a bit too busy, especially with movement. The logo choices work well, I think. As for the third jersey, I fell into my old pattern of just eliminating the third color, but it works out okay here because you have the contrast of light and dark between the two colors. Looking back, I might eliminate the yellow helmet and just go with the blue, just to avoid an overload of yellow. Execution note: accidentally put the primary logo instead of the shoulder patch next to the third jersey. Rookie mistake. Final Verdict: 8.5/10
Since I have two concepts in this post, I'm going to leave it up to y'all to nominate who you want for the COTW. Let us know in the comments.
On a final note, I want to point something out to anyone contributing to this site. I, like everyone else on the HJC team, was brought on because I have a particular taste in jerseys that is different from the other members of the staff. That's part of what makes this site work, the fact that it's got a wide variety of opinions on concepts that are brought from the different writers. For example, most of the other guys who write for HJC absolutely HATE the jersey template that I use, but I find that it's the most user friendly, especially if you're just starting out, and it works for me. This subjectivity means that we aren't the be-all-end-all of concept designs. If you think we're wrong about your work, stand up for it and let us know why in the comments. Even if it isn't your concept, if you think we got a COTW nominee wrong, feel free to let us know. This site is meant for your opinions just as much as ours. This is a community.
------------------------------------------
That's it for me this week, I'll see y'all next Friday!
Friday: First Post ft. Vegas' New Golden Knight
Reviewed by TC Moore
on
May 05, 2017
Rating:
7 comments:
Welcome to the writing team, TC, glad to have you! If you can make that template work for you, more the power to you!
Vegas signed their 2nd player today from the KHL, so now it's Duke and Shipachyov kicking a soccer ball together instead of just Duke kicking the ball to himself. Hopefully this team is competitive, put more importantly has nice jerseys!
COTW Nom to Brooks F's Wings concept. I had the same idea with the yoke for a contest back in the day and I'm glad to see someone do it better
Welcome to the team TC, good first post!
One correction though. Anthony C's "Vancouver" Canucks logo isn't his own creation. It's from the Calgary Canucks of the AJHL.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calgary_Canucks
I have to agree. I giving it to Brooks F. Detroit for COTW.
Shoot, at the time I wrote this I hadn't seen the news on the newest addition to the team. Oh well, maybe that's a topic for next week if jersey news is slow. Thanks for the update!
Great post TC! I especially like the thoroughness of your concept reviews.
Also I'll second Brooks' Red Wings concept for COTW. It's cool to see something wacky and unique for a team as traditional as the Wings (when it's done well, as this concept is).
Welcome to the team, TC! Looks like you're doing great so far. I'm actually gonna give my COTW nomination to Brooks' Stars concept, mainly because of just how much I love that hem stripe.
I like the idea of modernizing the red wings. That jersey is gorgeous. The only thing missing is updating the logo. It could be as simple as just changing the design of the wheel. Chand it to a Torq Thrust or Halibrand wheel and it still remains classic and becomes even more classic than it is. I'm torn about if the wings part of the logo needs changed or should remain as it is. Redwings ought to hire Chip Foose to design them an alternate when they allow those again.
Post a Comment